Abu Dharr asked a second and third time, receiving the same affirmative response. Finally, the Prophet added: "In defiance of Abu Dharr,"
" by Imam Bukhari. However, in the standard collection of , Hadith 172 falls under the " Book of Miscellany " ( Kitab al-Muqaddimat Hadith 172: The Burden of First Blood kitabul akib hadith 172
The Gatherer, at whose feet the people will be gathered on Resurrection Day. Abu Dharr asked a second and third time,